Doctor profile · Federal record

Dr. James Fenstermacher, PSYD

Clinical Psychologist · Clinical Psychologist · Clinical Psychologist · Crown Point, IN

  • NPI 1295181154
  • MIPS 72.3 / 100 · 2023
  • 10 yrs on file
  • Licensed in 3 states
  • Male
  • Group practice
  • No sanctions

Practice & contact

Operates at 3 locations .

NPPES Updated May 11, 2026
Primary practice
2100 N Main St Ste 304
Crown Point, IN 463071877
(574) 546-1900
fax (574) 546-1999
Additional location
40600 Ann Arbor RD E Ste 201
Plymouth, MI 481704675
Additional location
1821 Walden Office Sq Ste 400
Schaumburg, IL 601734273
Mailing address
Po Box 10299
Fort Wayne, IN 468510299

Credentials & registration

NPPES · NUCC
NPI registered
May 2016 — 10 yrs on file
Profile last updated
May 1, 2025
Specialty taxonomy
103TC0700X — NUCC code
State licenses (3)
Michigan #6301018918 · Illinois #071009285 · Indiana #20042942A

Federal sanctions & exclusions

OIG LEIE Updated May 11, 2026

No sanctions, exclusions or revocations on file

Checked against OIG LEIE on NPI 1295181154. Last verified May 11, 2026.

Medicare procedures · 2023

Top services delivered

CMS Provider Utilization
Total services
3,895
Distinct HCPCS
8
Medicare allowed
$192,519
HCPCS Description Services Patients Avg allowed
90832 Psychotherapy, 30 minutes 1,796 305 $72
90785 Psychiatric services complicated by communication factor 1,660 325 $14
96116 Exam of neurobehavioral status, first hour 123 123 $88
90791 Psychiatric diagnostic evaluation 102 102 $167
90785 Psychiatric services complicated by communication factor 87 44 $13
90832 Psychotherapy, 30 minutes 86 38 $64
90791 Psychiatric diagnostic evaluation 23 23 $145
96116 Exam of neurobehavioral status, first hour 18 18 $77

In context: peer comparison

Among 7 peers in this city , average services per provider: 392. This provider delivers 9.9× the peer median.

Medicare Part D · 2023

Top prescriptions

CMS Part D Prescriber
Total claims
12
Patients
0
Total drug cost
$76
Drug Type Claims Patients Total cost
Pantoprazole Sodium Generic 12 0 $76

Frequently asked questions

Auto-generated from federal data
What is Dr. James Fenstermacher's medical specialty?
Dr. James Fenstermacher practices Clinical Psychologist in Crown Point, IN.
Where does Dr. James Fenstermacher practice?
Dr. James Fenstermacher practices at 2100 N Main St Ste 304, Crown Point, IN 463071877. Office phone: 5745461900.
What is Dr. James Fenstermacher's NPI?
Dr. James Fenstermacher's National Provider Identifier (NPI) is 1295181154, issued by NPPES.
What procedures does Dr. James Fenstermacher commonly perform?
Top Medicare-reported procedures in 2023: Psychotherapy (HCPCS 90832); Psychiatric services complicated by communication factor (HCPCS 90785); Exam of neurobehavioral status, first hour (HCPCS 96116). Source: CMS Medicare Physician & Other Practitioners file.