Doctor profile · Federal record

Dr. Bethany Cataldi, D.O.

Facial Plastic Surgery Physician · Highland, IN

  • NPI 1205890886
  • 20 yrs on file
  • Female
  • Solo practice
  • No sanctions

Practice & contact

NPPES Updated May 11, 2026
Primary practice
2203 45Th St, Suite 'B'
Highland, IN 463222601
(219) 836-4820
fax (219) 836-5186
Mailing address
Po Box 958
Schererville, IN 463750958

Credentials & registration

NPPES · NUCC
NPI registered
April 2006 — 20 yrs on file
Profile last updated
November 15, 2016
Specialty taxonomy
207YS0123X — NUCC code
State license (1)
Indiana #02002695A
Medicaid
IN #200841030 A

Federal sanctions & exclusions

OIG LEIE Updated May 11, 2026

No sanctions, exclusions or revocations on file

Checked against OIG LEIE on NPI 1205890886. Last verified May 11, 2026.

Medicare procedures · 2023

Top services delivered

CMS Provider Utilization
Total services
785
Distinct HCPCS
10
Medicare allowed
$245,733
HCPCS Description Services Patients Avg allowed
99213 Established patient office or other outpatient visit, 20-29 minutes 278 198 $84
31231 Diagnostic exam of nasal passages using an endoscope 116 97 $173
92557 Comprehensive hearing and speech recognition test 68 64 $35
92570 Comprehensive hearing test 68 64 $30
92588 Placement of ear probe for computerized measurement of repeated sounds with interpretation and report 68 64 $32
70486 Ct scan of face without contrast 44 43 $39
69220 Simple removal of skin debris and drainage of mastoid cavity 36 35 $92
31295 Dilation of nasal sinus using an endoscope 29 27 $2,058
31298 Dilation of sphenoid and frontal nasal sinus using an endoscope 29 27 $4,365
99203 New patient office or other outpatient visit, 30-44 minutes 18 18 $99

In context: peer comparison

Among 1 peers in Highland Facial Plastic Surgery Physician, average services per provider: 65. This provider delivers 12× the peer median.

Medicare Part D · 2023

Top prescriptions

CMS Part D Prescriber
Total claims
2,429
Patients
1,410
Total drug cost
$28,188
Drug Type Claims Patients Total cost
Montelukast Sodium Generic 413 216 $4,790
Prednisone Generic 322 178 $1,500
Levocetirizine Dihydrochloride Generic 258 141 $5,447
Methylprednisolone Generic 233 166 $1,927
Pantoprazole Sodium Generic 198 92 $2,640
Alprazolam Generic 187 59 $1,344
Hydroxyzine Hcl Generic 139 76 $1,685
Azithromycin Generic 132 103 $755
Fluticasone Propionate Generic 128 81 $1,231
Clindamycin Hcl Generic 85 55 $848

Frequently asked questions

Auto-generated from federal data
What is Dr. Bethany Cataldi's medical specialty?
Dr. Bethany Cataldi practices Facial Plastic Surgery Physician in Highland, IN.
Where does Dr. Bethany Cataldi practice?
Dr. Bethany Cataldi practices at 2203 45Th St, Highland, IN 463222601. Office phone: 2198364820.
What is Dr. Bethany Cataldi's NPI?
Dr. Bethany Cataldi's National Provider Identifier (NPI) is 1205890886, issued by NPPES.
What procedures does Dr. Bethany Cataldi commonly perform?
Top Medicare-reported procedures in 2023: Established patient office or other outpatient visit (HCPCS 99213); Diagnostic exam of nasal passages using an endoscope (HCPCS 31231); Comprehensive hearing and speech recognition test (HCPCS 92557). Source: CMS Medicare Physician & Other Practitioners file.