Doctor profile · Federal record

Dr. Justin Fallacaro, PA-C

Surgical Physician Assistant (CMS: Physician Assistant) · Middletown, NY

  • NPI 1659920767
  • Accepts Medicare
  • MIPS 74.4 / 100 · 2023
  • 6 yrs in practice
  • Male
  • Group practice
  • No sanctions

Practice & contact

Operates at 2 locations .

NPPES Updated May 11, 2026
Primary practice
707 E Main St
Middletown, NY 109402650
(845) 333-7575
fax (845) 333-7201
Additional location
68 Harris Bushville RD
Harris, NY 12742
(845) 333-8909

Credentials & registration

NPPES · NUCC
NPI registered
September 2019 — 7 yrs on file
Profile last updated
October 16, 2024
Year of graduation
2020 — 6 yrs since
Specialty taxonomy
363AS0400X — NUCC code
State license (1)
New York #024728
Medicaid
NY #06045005

Federal sanctions & exclusions

OIG LEIE Updated May 11, 2026

No sanctions, exclusions or revocations on file

Checked against OIG LEIE on NPI 1659920767. Last verified May 11, 2026.

Medicare procedures · 2023

Top services delivered

CMS Provider Utilization
Total services
40
Distinct HCPCS
2
Medicare allowed
$3,233
HCPCS Description Services Patients Avg allowed
99232 Subsequent hospital care with moderate levelof medical decision making, if using time, at least 35 minutes 29 24 $72
99239 Hospital discharge day management, more than 30 minutes 11 11 $104

In context: peer comparison

Among 11 peers in Middletown Surgical Physician Assistant, average services per provider: 257. This provider delivers 0.2× the peer median.

Medicare Part D · 2023

Top prescriptions

CMS Part D Prescriber
Total claims
45
Patients
44
Total drug cost
$263
Drug Type Claims Patients Total cost
Meloxicam Generic 16 16 $126
Oxycodone Hcl Generic 15 15 $72
Tramadol Hcl Generic 14 13 $65

Hospital affiliations

CMS Hospital Compare

Frequently asked questions

Auto-generated from federal data
What is Dr. Justin Fallacaro's medical specialty?
Dr. Justin Fallacaro practices Surgical Physician Assistant in Middletown, NY.
Where does Dr. Justin Fallacaro practice?
Dr. Justin Fallacaro practices at 707 E Main St, Middletown, NY 109402650. Office phone: 8453337575.
What is Dr. Justin Fallacaro's NPI?
Dr. Justin Fallacaro's National Provider Identifier (NPI) is 1659920767, issued by NPPES.
Does Dr. Justin Fallacaro accept Medicare assignment?
Yes. Dr. Justin Fallacaro accepts Medicare assignment, meaning Medicare-allowed amounts are accepted as full payment for covered services.
What procedures does Dr. Justin Fallacaro commonly perform?
Top Medicare-reported procedures in 2023: Subsequent hospital care with moderate levelof medical decision making (HCPCS 99232); Hospital discharge day management (HCPCS 99239). Source: CMS Medicare Physician & Other Practitioners file.